D1 Training Wins Arbitration Case Against Former Franchisee

An independent arbitrator has ruled in favor of D1 Training in a dispute brought by a former franchise owner. The decision rejected all claims against the fitness franchise, including allegations of fraud and misrepresentation.

The case involved Alex Nicholas, who previously operated a D1 Training facility in Naples, Florida. Nicholas filed the lawsuit against D1 Sports Franchise in April 2025 in Williamson County, Tennessee, where the company is headquartered.

Following four days of arbitration proceedings in February, arbitrator John T. Blankenship issued his decision on May 18. He found that the former franchisee had not presented sufficient evidence to support the allegations made against D1 Training.

D1 Training Moves Forward After Legal Decision

With the dispute now resolved, D1 Training says its attention remains on supporting franchise owners, serving athletes and strengthening its national franchise network.

CEO Will Bartholomew said the company is pleased to have the matter concluded and will continue working toward its long-term mission. That includes helping franchisees develop successful businesses while providing athletes with a high-quality training experience.

The ruling allows the fitness franchise to move forward without the uncertainty created by the legal proceedings. It also comes as D1 Training continues investing in tools, systems and coaching standards across its locations.

Franchisee Support Remains a Priority

Founded in 2002, D1 Training has grown into a nationwide fitness franchise offering athletic training programs for children, teenagers and adults.

Franchise owners receive assistance in several areas, including operations, marketing, business coaching and continuing education. These resources are designed to help local owners manage their businesses while maintaining a consistent customer experience throughout the franchise system.

D1 Training has also launched new programs aimed at improving athlete development and giving customers clearer ways to measure their progress.

One of those initiatives is D1 Verified, a coach-certified testing program created for athletes between the ages of 14 and 18. The system tracks performance over time and gives young athletes measurable information about their development.

The company’s Athlete Performance Index uses combine-style assessments to evaluate athletic ability. Results are converted into a five-star rating based on benchmarks connected to college recruiting standards.

D1 Training has also expanded its coach certification programs. The goal is to establish consistent coaching expectations, improve athlete progression and maintain training quality across franchise locations.

A Training Model Inspired by College Athletics

D1 Training offers coach-led workouts built around the structure and intensity of a Division I college strength and conditioning program. Sessions are designed to improve athletic performance for clients at different ages and experience levels.

Bartholomew’s own athletic background helped shape the company. He played football at the University of Tennessee, was part of its 1998 national championship team and later served as team captain. After signing with the Denver Broncos, a career-ending injury led him toward a new path in sports performance and business.

Over the years, D1 Training has received recognition from several fitness and business organizations. With the arbitration matter behind it, the brand is now returning its full attention to franchisee growth, coaching development and athlete performance.

Explore more about D1 Training franchise opportunities.